The Feedback Loop: How Bad Rubrics Create Their Own Crisis

Sun, 23 Nov 2025 11:00:00 -0600

Imagine you’re selecting students for an advanced physics class.

You test them on basic arithmetic. The top scorers get into advanced physics.

Some of them struggle. They weren’t ready for physics—they were just good at arithmetic.

Your response: Raise the bar on arithmetic testing.

Require 95th percentile instead of 90th. Add a speed component. Demand perfection on multiplication tables.

More students fail to qualify. Fewer get into advanced physics.

But here’s the problem: You’re still not testing physics readiness.

When Ready Isn't Enough: How Rubrics Measure the Wrong Things

Tue, 18 Nov 2025 10:00:00 -0600

My daughter didn’t qualify for math acceleration from first grade to third grade.

Not because she wasn’t ready for third grade. She was.

She didn’t qualify because the rubric measured how well she performed at first grade math—not whether she was ready for third grade math.

These are two entirely different questions.

The Evidence: Ready for Third Grade

By the end of first grade, here’s what my daughter demonstrated:

Advanced Coursework: My daughter successfully completed both SMART advanced 2nd grade math sessions and SMART advanced 3rd grade math sessions. Both programs placed her with older students working on grade-level-ahead material. Her teachers described her work as “appropriate for her level”—she was thriving with this advanced content, not struggling.

Rubric Analysis on Acceleration Denied

The Feedback Loop: How Bad Rubrics Create Their Own Crisis

When Ready Isn't Enough: How Rubrics Measure the Wrong Things

The Evidence: Ready for Third Grade